Malaysia’s school discipline debate erupted in October 2025 after a string of violent incidents exposed deep cracks in classroom safety. It began with the Malacca School Gang Rape on 2 October, where four Form 5 students allegedly assaulted a Form 3 girl in a classroom at Alor Gajah, two even recording the act on their phones. The case barely registered beyond local outrage.
Image: Malacca school gang rape
Image: Kedah school gang rape case
Ten days later, on 12 October, the Kedah School Gang Rape followed—three students and one former student arrested for gang-raping a girl and sharing nude recordings online. School discipline chatter grew, but remained contained.
Then, on 14 October, a 14-year-old boy fatally stabbed his 16-year-old schoolmate in Bandar Utama, Petaling Jaya. On the same day, the Ministry of Education (MOE) issued a firm statement:
“Caning Won’t Be Used as a Disciplinary Tool.”
That declaration became the tipping point.
What followed was a 67x surge in online engagements, transforming quiet murmurings into a thunderous netizen-media demand for the return of rotan—once a standard tool under strict guidelines, now a symbol of a “shaped right” past.
Yet, just three days later, on 17 October 2025, MOE clarified: educational caning remains allowed under strict SOPs, where principals can delegate authority to teachers via written consent—but only for discipline, never abuse. The government plays a central role in shaping school discipline policy, and both law and government policy regulate the use of caning in schools. The MOE further clarified that caning is only permitted under specific circumstances, and public caning is not allowed under current guidelines. These punishments, including caning and other disciplinary measures, are enforced by adults such as teachers and school administrators, who are responsible for upholding discipline and shaping these practices. The existence of laws and regulations restricts or governs corporal punishment in schools, ensuring that all actions comply with legal standards.
VOLUME & ENGAGEMENT
Engagements Exploded 67x After Kedah School Gang Rape
Before the Kedah School Incident (2–12 Oct, ~450 Total Engagements):
Quiet murmurings with the Melaka Gang Rape barely registering. School discipline chatter stayed small; conversation about school caning started to emerge.
Peak (13–16 Oct, ~30,430 Total Engagements):
Daily engagement surged from 13 October from 184 to 1,745 engagements on 13 October, then peaked at 10,464 on 15 October, an overall of 67x leap from the pre-Kedah total engagements driven overwhelmingly by the Bandar Utama School Stabbing, with the Melaka and Kedah rape cases adding fuel, all clashing with MOE’s hardline “Caning Won’t Be Used as Disciplinary Tool” stance. Public outrage erupted nationwide.
Post-Peak (17–27 Oct, ~11,592 Total Engagements):
Sustained engagements driven by parental outrage, teacher testimonies, some politicians’ voices and PM Anwar’s clear support for limited caning on the palms only, under strict guidelines.
The 67x surge, ignited by the Kedah school incident, reveals a nation at breaking point over school safety and discipline.
CHANNEL DISTRIBUTION
Engagement across various online platforms
Instagram’s 61% dominance (27,164 engagements) reveals it as the emotional flashpoint for Gen Z and millennial parents sharing rotan-era nostalgia and outrage.
Instagram’s Nostalgia Fuel
“Zaman Saya Beza” Reel Ignites Gen X & Millennial Discipline Debate
The @nasidailymy’s reel (562k views, 36k likes, 500 comments, 3,127 reposts) used Basshunter’s “Boten Anna” to revive 2007–2012 shuffle battles, turning school corridors and classrooms into impromptu dance floors with Gen Z students sliding, spinning, and syncing in joyful chaos. Gen X and Millennials flooded the comment section as a referendum on rotan, contrasting shuffle-era “small” mischief such as untucked shirts, low socks, dancing in class, breakdancing, hip hop moves, bringing jewellery, comic books, or “bahan terlarang” like CDs and Bluetooth earpieces with today’s horrors of rape, stabbing, and murder. Netizens reminisced: “Zaman dulu isu terbesar cikgu ialah budak suka menari, skang?” and “Paling teruk koyak kasut barai, simple je dulu,” while some mourned the shift from “settle or battle” dance-offs to knife fights.
The nostalgia and debate highlight not just a generational gap but also deeper questions about how Malaysia’s society and values are changing over time. These shifting values echo the broader challenges discussed in RMK13 Vision vs Reality, where Malaysia’s reform goals are tested against the realities of education, economy, and youth development.
VOICES IN THE STORM
Key figures driving Malaysia’s caning debate
PM Anwar Ibrahim:
“Limited Palm-Only Caning, Under Strict Rules—My Teacher Days Taught Me That”
Education Minister Fadhlina Sidek:
“Caning is not the solution, focus on education.”
Dr Akmal Saleh:
Calls for CCTVs, Mental Health Screenings & Return of Rotans in Schools
Lim Guan Eng:
“Reintroduce Rotan with Safeguards and CCTVs Now!”
KEY THEMES & SENTIMENT BREAKDOWN
What Captivated Audiences About School Caning?
KEY THEMES BREAKDOWN
Discipline & Rotan Nostalgia Dominate the Conversation
“rotan”, “bring”, “back”, “school”, “students”, “teacher”, “generation”, “parents”, “discipline”, “old”, “wrong”, “bullying”, “hard”, “methods”, “shaped”, “many”, “kids”, “carried”, “person”, “even”, “stop”, “not”, “snowflake”, and “caning” dominated the cloud, echoing a thunderous netizen-media demand to revive caning as the only proven cure for a lost, “shaped wrong” generation.
Strict System Required & Calls For Immediate Action
The words such as “better”, “deserve”, “reset”, “factory”, “correct”, “next”, “perfect”, “public”, “right”, “give”, “change”, “developed”, “nations”, “hot”, “sun”, “nonsense”, “complain”, and “the best” reflected surge in calls for strict discipline systems and immediate execution needed.
Accountability & Education
“Home”, “scold”, “children”, “people”, “time”, “self”, “issue”, “action”, “outside” and “class” demanded parents and schools reclaim control. Terms like “good”, “sure”, “slap”, “guns”, and “fine” are warnings about tough love; without it, chaos wins.
SENTIMENT BREAKDOWN
Positive (80%)
Netizens overwhelmingly celebrated the return of caning as a no-nonsense fix for classroom chaos, sharing nostalgic stories of “shaped right” childhoods and praising leaders pushing for teacher empowerment and palm-only rules. Excitement peaked over promises of CCTV upgrades, more counsellors, and strict guidelines to restore order without abuse.
Negative (15%)
Critics slammed caning as outdated trauma, warning of teacher abuse and mental health risks in a “snowflake” era. Some mocked calls for rotan as regressive, preferring counselling, parental accountability, and modern safety tech over corporal punishment.
Neutral (5%)
A small group discussed policy details factually, such as MOE’s rejection on the school caning, budget for wardens, or UNICEF-aligned child voice initiatives, without strong emotion, focusing on implementation logistics and balanced reform.
Final Insights: The Rotan’s Quiet Return
The data tells a clear story: Malaysia craves order.
From untucked shirts to recorded assaults, the leap in severity has shattered the illusion of safety. 80% of the conversation yearns for the rotan not as punishment, but as a reset button for a “shaped wrong” generation.
Yet beneath the outrage lies a critical update: MOE clarified on 17 October 2025 that educational caning remains allowed under strict SOPs, where principals can delegate authority to teachers via written consent but only for discipline, never abuse.
The question is no longer “Will the rotan return?”
It’s “Has it already returned quietly, under new rules?”
The 67x surge wasn’t just noise.
It was a NATIONAL CONFESSION!
Powered by Dataxet, these insights help transform challenges into opportunities. As a leading social listening and social media monitoring company, we help you maximise your media strategies through actionable insights, leveraging social listening and social media monitoring to strengthen your brand and stay ahead of trends. Get in touch with our team to turn insights into impact.
Email: info@dataxet.nama.com.my
Follow on LinkedIn: DATAXET MALAYSIA
Follow on Facebook: DATAXET MALAYSIA
